This step-by-step guide will help you measure how long it takes subscribers to make their first purchase after signing up for your email list.
Step 1: Create a Segment in Klaviyo
Go to Lists & Segments and create a new segment with the following condition:
- Person has Subscribed to Email Marketing at least once in the last 365 days
Name the segment something like: Subscribed in Last 365 Days

Step 2: Export the Segment
Click into your new segment and export it to CSV. Make sure the export includes:
EmailFirst Active- Your custom profile property for
First Purchase Date Note: I've added this custom property to all my client accounts since 2017. It's included in the Reliable Revenue Klaviyo tutorials as well. If you don’t have this field in your account, you’ll need to retrieve the first purchase date from your ecommerce platform instead.
Step 3: Clean Your Data in Google Sheets
Open the CSV in Google Sheets. Remove:
- Test emails
- Any rows where
First Purchase Dateis blank
Step 4: Calculate Days to Purchase
Add a new column titled Days to Purchase. In the first row of that column, enter:
=IF(OR(ISBLANK(B2), ISBLANK(C2)), "", INT(C2) - INT(B2))
This calculates the number of full days between subscribing and purchasing.
Format the column as a Number (not Date).


Step 5: Group by Conversion Window
Add another column titled Conversion Window and enter this formula:
=IF(D2="", "No Purchase", IF(D2<=7, "0–7 days", IF(D2<=30, "8–30 days", IF(D2<=90, "31–90 days", "90+ days"))))
This creates readable categories for your data.


Step 6: Create a Pivot Table
- Highlight your entire dataset
- Go to Insert → Pivot table, choose “New sheet”
- In the Pivot Editor:
-
Rows: Add
Conversion Window -
Values: Add
Emailand summarize by COUNTA
-
Rows: Add
This gives you a count of how many people fall into each conversion window.

Step 7: Visualize with a Chart (Optional)
Click anywhere in the pivot table, then click the chart icon in the top toolbar. Choose a Pie chart or Bar chart.

Case Study: Sew Hungry Hippie
From 3352 subscribers who made a purchase in the last year:
- 56.4% converted within 0–7 days
- 67% converted within 30 days
- Only 22.5% converted after 90 days
This shows that most conversions happen in the first week, and the welcome flow plays a key role.
By measuring this for your own store, you can:
- Optimize your welcome flow timing
- Identify drop-off windows
- Create benchmark goals for list conversion
Track it quarterly to measure improvements over time.
If you want reliable revenue, this is where to start.
Natalie, founder of Sew Hungry Hippie, is a member of Reliable Revenue and the Mastermind Accelerator where I coach Shopify store owners how to get predictable and reliable revenue with step-by-step, proven email marketing strategies.
